Evolving humanity, emerging worlds

Manchester, UK; 5th-10th August 2013

(V09)

Ethnographic films made by women about women: is there a feminist visual anthropology?

Location Chemistry G.54
Date and Start Time 06 Aug, 2013 at 09:00

Convenors

Metje Postma (ICAOS/Faculty of Social and Behavioral Sciences) email
Joceny Pinheiro (UFBA - Universidade Federal da Bahia) email
Laura Coppens (University of Zurich) email
Mail All Convenors

Short Abstract

In this session we will discuss whether or not ethnographic films made by women and about women give expression to another perspective in the world. Do they reveal specific kinds of aesthetics and sensitivity in relation to the subjects filmed in the field?

Long Abstract

The fields of feminism and postcolonialism intersect through their shared concern with resisting the enduring masculinist and heterosexual ideologies and structures of power that sustain Western-situated normative views of reality. Feminist and postcolonial scholars have challenged the authority of Westerns discourses of truth by calling attention to their constructed nature, and by investigating the everyday-life politics involved in struggles over gender inequality, sexual orientation, race and ethnicity. In this session we will discuss whether or not ethnographic films made by women and about women have been influenced by feminist and postcolonial concerns and/or give expression to another point of view about the world, revealing different social relations with, and/or specific kinds of aesthetics and sensitivity in relation to the subjects filmed in the field.

We will also explore why, unlike in written anthropology, discourses about visual anthropology as a discipline seldom referred to the work of female anthropologist filmmakers, and/or why female anthropologist filmmakers seem less prone to profile themselves in these discourses. Ironically, there are today more women enrolled in visual anthropology courses than ever before. What are they doing? In what kinds of professional and academic domains do they circulate their work? How can we begin rewriting the recent history of visual anthropology in order to include their practices?

Chair: Rossella Ragazzi

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.

Papers

A dialogue between anthropologists and documentary filmmakers in India

Author: Giulia Battaglia (LSE/SOAS)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

Drawing on my PhD research, this paper will explore the similitude existing between the anthropological approach to representation and documentary film practices in India. I shall argue that both practices share common features and call for further collaboration in both the academic and practice-based fields.

Long Abstract

Drawing on my PhD research, this paper will explore the similitude existing between the anthropological approach to representation and documentary film practices in India. I shall argue that both practices share common features and call for further collaboration in both the academic and practice-based fields. In line with Fred Myers (1991), I suggest that anthropologists are not alone in their interpretative activity. Documentary filmmakers (as well as other practitioners dealing with representation) are, in fact, involved in a similar act of 'intellectual catharsis' (Sontag 1986) to the extent that, as Robert Edmond (1974) analyses, the significance of any documentary film can be interpreted through an anthropological lens. The Indian subcontinent provides a valid example of this similitude and provokes anthropologists to start thinking beyond anthropology. A combination of documentary film practices (from art, ethnography, activism, performance to non-linear images and video-installations) making use of different technologies (from celluloid and video to HD devices and digital platforms) is proliferating in the subcontinent. These practices of 'image-making' (see Favero 2009, Basu 2008, Ramey 2011) are in line with the field of anthropology, dealing with media and visual images. For decades, this area of anthropology has worked towards the integration of technology and images in the process of knowing ethnographically, and today is increasingly emphasising this feature calling for further theorisation (see Banks and Ruby 2011) but also for regional specifications. The Indian example that I will bring to this panel will help us thinking in an interdisciplinary way but also through possibilities existing between the academic-practitioner relationships.

A skin of light - aesthetics and ethics of affect and porosity in female ethnographic filmmaking.

Author: Cathy Greenhalgh (University of the Arts, London)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

A sensory anthropology could allow us to rethink approaches to the female ethnographic subject, aligning point-of-view and optics with a deliberate porosity and diversity in feminist reflexive filmmaking. We can take a lead from new studies of female experimental artist filmmakers which evidence an aesthetics of affect and visual hapticity.

Long Abstract

Seeking a vivid 'synthesis of Vertov's cine-eye and Flaherty's participating camera', Rouch compares camerawork with 'the improvisation of the bullfighter in front of the bull' (The Camera and Man, 1973). Capturing and framing the image whilst habituating the subject assume the ubiquitous apparatus of the camera, yet we can rethink point-of-view and the optics of focus and light, aligning them with a deliberate porosity and diversity in feminist reflexive filmmaking. Luce Irigaray, arguing with Nietzsche on the nature of water (1991), suggests it is feminine because it encompasses equal multiple points-of-view; 'she undoes all perspective'. The sensory turn in anthropology (eg: Pink, 2009) allows a reclaimed historiography of womens' approaches to the ethnographic subject. In particular, we can review uses of an aesthetics of affect and visual hapticity (Marks, 2000), in womens' film work and indigenous media collaboration (Deger, 2006); perhaps taking a lead from claims in new studies of female experimental artist filmmakers (Best, 2011; Levitin et al, 2003; Minh-Ha, 1989, 2011; Petrolle and Wexman, 2005). Does a sensory approach recast notions of documentary reflexivity, visual and aural engagement and female subjectivity (Lebow, 2011; Ellis, 2012)? This paper is influenced by ethnographic work with cinematographers and my interviews with female professionals, and by my own practice as a filmmaker using cinematography as ethnography in approaches to material culture, time, place, memory and female point-of-view. I will show clips, where women are the subject, which seem to amplify a "female eye" (Minh-Ha, Longinotto, Greenhalgh).

Bringing out the Unknown

Author: Katherine Aigner  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

Aboriginal knowledge holder Lorraine Mafi-Williams squatted ‘illegally’ on traditional land to teach and defend a womens birthing lake from imminent destruction. As local council rangers moved in to evict her I filmed and we collaboratively conveyed her world ‘I want to bring out the unknown’ she said.

Long Abstract

From 1997-2001 I filmed Australian Aboriginal Elder, knowledge holder, filmmaker and Human Rights advocate, Lorraine Mafi-Williams as she 'squatted' on traditional land to teach and defend a women's birthing lake from imminent destruction. She returned home from the UK and USA in the 90s, globally known but under threat of being locally ignored. After a women's weekend retreat teaching about the land, lake and history, 5 male council rangers moved in to dismantle her camp and evict her.

"We can, under law, arrest you" he said. "But that's your law" she replied. "No, that's the Common law" … "But I'm an Aboriginal, I belong to this land".

The rangers acted illegally, finally handing her a '30 day compliance period' letter. I filmed the event - under threat of being arrested - and she was able to use the footage to negotiate with local council and re-establish her camp where she remained for the next 4 years, transmitting environmental and cultural knowledge to 100s of people from Australia and overseas. She revealed a parallel word. "I want to bring out the unknown… so we can all move together as one". Being Aboriginal, the personal was often, if not always political. In my presentation I discuss how we collaboratively tried to portray her world and cultural teachings and the challenges we faced in conveying cross-cultural 'perspective shifts'.

Lorraine's activism inspired me and I went on to make an award winning film Australian Atomic Confessions (2005) which screened in 25 festivals in over 14 countries.

Growing Old Together: Visualizing and Reflecting Change

Author: Beate Engelbrecht (Max Planck Institute for the Study of Religious and Ethnic Diversity)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

She is slightly older than I am. We know each other since years. She worked, did pottery, raised her children, migrated, worked and looked after her family again. I worked, did research, filmed, and taught. I filmed her family; she grasped that my filmic records turned into being her family history.

Long Abstract

Mexico 1980: I wanted to write a dissertation on pottery in the context of developmental anthropology. I arrived at a village, at a potter family house, and stayed. They kindly accepted me, we shared our time, and I managed to stay in contact with them till today. 1989: We (my cameraman and I) started an ethnographic film project portraying the potter family. I wanted to show the manifold activities of the women, the daily life, and the economic implications. Later I asked the main protagonist to comment the film. She did it, but she was not feeling very comfortable with it. She was a modest person and she was not sure of the usefulness of the film - till her grandchildren from the US visited her. Suddenly the film became a piece of family history. 2000: She moved to Florida to look after her grandchildren. 2001: We visited her, and she started to use our video camera to record her life there and her reflections on living in the US. I visited her once in a while and the people in the sending village, recording changes here and there. We used the little time we had together to discuss the difficulties she was encountering - very often off camera. Through her I got deep insights in a migrant family life, the worries and hopes. I gathered a lot of visual material, but I still search for a way to make sense out of it without compromising the protagonist's family.

Performing loss and longing through album photographs in my bereaved family, an auto ethnographic case study.

Author: Evangelia Katsaiti (Nottingham Trent University)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

This paper will consider the use of photography as a ‘featherweight portable museum’ (Sontag 1977) by my family, in order to mediate loss and thus adjust and cope with bereavement. The photographic work ‘Dedicated to’ is a photographic art project that consists of 5 sequences of photographic narratives visually relating my devastating emotions from five losses of loved ones. While speaking my story of loss of my father I will aim to make gender politics visible and narrate my process of renegotiation through my art photography of the language that inscribes my memory. The point of this analysis is to disseminate through the lens of personal experience any possible links between culture and self.

Long Abstract

My home town, Perama , is a city that evolves around the industry of traveling and transport in which the family album is often used significantly to remember and communicate the past as well as define an emotional space signifying stability.

The photographic narratives I have assembled into art photography assisted me to articulate and express visually my grief for the death of my father. I will decode visual language rituals involving stereotype family photographs used to externalize feelings of intimacy, and thus assert the connection of the expression of the personal with the political. Walkerdine clarifies of how self-disclosure in auto ethnography is intended to be a way of understanding subjectivity, and that is when "the confessional becomes reactionary". (Walkerdine 1997). Self-directed art photography mediated the reconstruction of the preferred stories sought by me, and thus affected the emotional and cultural landscape of grieving within my family, from which I have been reciprocally influenced. The language of the family photograph as an artefact seriously infested what I choose to remember or forget as well what I chose to be through what I remember. My art photography as a research tool challenged the language that inscribes my memory allowing me through the renegotiating of my relationship with the power struggles intermitted to photography to redefine myself through new enabling identities.

QWOCMAP: (self-) representations of queer women "of color" in their audiovisual productions in the U.S..

Author: Glauco Ferreira  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

Through ethnographic research, in this paper I will discuss about films made by people who self-identify as "queer women of color," articulated around the "Queer Women of Color Media Arts Project" (QWOCMAP), training project of filmmakers and videographers aimed at women, queer subjects, people "of color" and immigrants in the region of the San Francisco Bay. In the Intersection of the fields of feminism and postcolonialism, these films are made thinking in the effort to built other ways to represent the “queer women of color”, proposing visual ways to resist to the normative views about these women. In comparative exercise proposed here I seek to consider the context of production of these films, thinking in the ambivalences of such context: Are these movies "native documentaries" or they share the assumptions expressed in ethnographic films made by women? Or, in another way of thinking, they could be both types of films?

Long Abstract

Through ethnographic research, the purpose of this investigation concerns the analysis of self-representations expressed in media, made by people who self-identify as "queer women of color," articulated around the "Queer Women of Color Media Arts Project" (QWOCMAP), "training project of filmmakers and videographers" aimed at women, queer subjects, people "of color" and immigrants in the region of the San Francisco Bay, CA, U.S..The research seeks to understand how well these initiatives relate to the production of local meanings and self-representations into audiovisual media about the "queer women of color", thinking, at the same time, as an opportunity to reflect on these creations and about their production context as a field of disputes. This field provides fertile ground for research, considering that this field is possibly configurated through various processes and modes of subjectivity for the constitution of subjects, intersecting differences, ie, crisscrossing intersections between categories of identication (of gender, sexuality, "race/ethnicity ", nationality.). In the Intersection of the fields of feminism and postcolonialism, these films are made thinking in the effort to built other ways to represent the "queer women of color", proposing visual ways to resist to the normative views about these women. In comparative exercise proposed here I seek to consider the context of production of these films, thinking in the ambivalences of such context: Are these movies "native documentaries" or they share the assumptions expressed in ethnographic films made by women? Or, in another way of thinking, they could be both types of films?

to me Her voice seldom heard OR even rarely empathized with :A documentary film on Prostitution.

Author: Bhanumathy Govindaswamy (EFL University)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

A woman shooting a documentary on sex workers is unacceptable in India today. My family, neighbors and colleagues were appalled that I visited such areas, went to police stations and interacted with such a class of people. I was an observer in their saga of suffering and exploitation, but was made aware of the distance between my-self as an observer and them as exploited subjects of a cruel system. The skin-crawling looks given me by their clients made me aware of the horrors such women face.

Long Abstract

The Hindu caste system has many manifestations. In addition to social hierarchization, it also enables the creation of roles for women so that they may be easily exploited: the devadasi system in some parts of India is an instance. The Institutional rituals whereby the priest was authorized, if he chose to, to have intercourse with any lower caste women in the society who wished to enroll with his temple . She of course has to remain unmarried and subsist on ceremonial begging. Or she ends up in a brothel. Prostitution in India is neither legal or illegal.

The women become commercial sex workers because of poverty, broken family/marriage or social exploitation. Research reveals that women are forced into prostitution by 76% women agents and 24% by men agents like neighbors, family friends, money lenders, lovers, husband, indulge women into prostitution. . Many of them infected with HIV and AIDS end theirs lives when their family members isolate them, or force their daughters to turn to prostitution to survive.

Many awareness program-mes are conducted to educated the prostitute regarding health, safe sex, banking loan for children s education and marriages by Doctors and NGOs. Through a film on sex workers, one brings to awareness a sad reality

Woman daily life in Visual Anthropology: 1977-2013!

Author: Nadine Wanono ( CEMAf- CNRS)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

What are the specificities and consequences of being a woman when you decided to dedicate your life to Visual Anthropology?

Long Abstract

What are the specificities and consequences of being a woman when you decided to dedicate your life to Visual Anthropology?

We could start from the training as a cameraperson in order to avoid the "power relationship" with technicians, to the fieldwork shared with women colleagues, to the decision of dedicating your work to the women daily life in the Dogon country.

My choices permitted to better understand the ways the Dogon society could be perceived by Dogon men, the crucial importance of men rituals and that daily life was probably one of the most difficult aspect of the society to render. Also, I clearly understood it was not "the cup of tea" for festivals and in the French cultural surrounding. The last exhibit at Quai Branly Museum was exemplar by presenting 330 exceptional "pieces" from international collections without giving any explanation regarding the social surrounding of the population. Women were still in the backstage waiting for the next century to be allowed to have their own existence, rights and proper beliefs.

As I'm starting, with a woman colleague of mine, a new fieldwork on the biggest French maternity in Mayotte island, where 6.000 to 8000 babies are born every year, during this presentation I will describe precisely the reasons, consequences, specificities and the evolution of a woman' eye behind the viewfinder.

Women Make Movies: Kim Longinotto and her contribution to a female perspective

Author: Susanne Hammacher (Royal Anthropological Institute)  email
Mail All Authors

Short Abstract

Kim Longinotto’ internationally acclaimed documentaries are well recognised within ethnographic film festival circles. From a distributor’s perspective we like to position the impact of her documentaries within visual anthropology and compare with feedbacks from women’s filmmaker networks such as Woman Make Movies.

Long Abstract

Kim Longinotto' internationally acclaimed documentaries are well recognised in anthropological circles, are regularly screened at ethnographic film festivals and used in teaching. All but one of her last 14 documentaries take a female perspective, portraying women and addressing topics such as FGM, domestic abuse, divorce or woman's rights with sensitivity and compassion. Using interviews with the filmmaker and citations of her films this contribution will analyse her approach to her female subjects and her practice. From a distributor's perspective we like to position the impact of her documentaries within visual anthropology and compare with feedbacks from women's filmmaker networks such as Woman Make Movies.

This panel is closed to new paper proposals.

This congress is sponsored by:

Wenner-Gren logo