Evolving humanity, emerging worlds
Manchester, UK; 5th-10th August 2013
(SE24)
Exclusion of de-notified (ex-criminal tribes) and nomadic tribes in India: issues and challenges for inclusion
Location Alan Turing Building G113
Date and Start Time 07 Aug, 2013 at 14:30
Convenors
Chandrakant Puri (SNDT Women's University, Mumbai.)
email
Mahesh Chougule (Walchand College of Arts and Science)
email
Jagdish Jadhav (CSRD-ISWR)
email
Mail All Convenors
Short Abstract
Certain communities in India were known as Criminal Tribes.DNT and NT are the most neglected and discriminated marginalized section of Indian Society who are socially excluded.This panel aims to explain the process of exclusion and suggest strategies for their inclusive development.
Long Abstract
Certain communities now called as Denotified were known as Criminal Tribes by the Britishers as Criminal Tribes Act 1871 was imposed on these communities to control and regulate those who challenged the colonial rule. DNT and NT (Nomadic Tribes) are the most neglected and discriminated marginalized section of Indian Society. Pastoral, hunter gatherers, traders, transporters, craft workers, entertainers, foragers and such communities are being socially excluded. They are losing their traditional forms of livelihood due to micro and macro impact of the globalization The subsequent de-notification by repealing the abovementioned Act released these communities in 1952 without any rehabilitation plan compelled them to be a part of wandering life.
One of the key problems in putting these communities on to India's developmental map is non-availability of authentic data. Since most of the communities are nomads- they do not get enumerated in the census and development initiatives hence are away from the fruits of development even today. Increasing atrocities, violations of human rights are accepted norms now. They cannot even exercise the right to vote due to non-availability of election card and are away from development due to non-availablity of basic documents such as land entitlements, ration card and Below Poverty Line (BPL) card.
This panel aims at highlighting the exclusion of such vulnerable communities and suggesting strategies for their inclusive development. The idea is to highlight the issues before the world community and get ideas on 'best practices for inclusion'.
This panel is closed to new paper proposals.
Papers
Plight of Nomadic and Semi Tribes in Maharashtra: Lessons for Inclusion
Short Abstract
The issues of De-notified, Nomadic Tribes and Semi Nomadic Tribes such as Identity, classification and enumeration, exclusion in welfare scheme, obstacles in exercising civil and political rights and possible affirmative actions have discussed in this paper.
Long Abstract
De-notified, (DNT) Nomadic Tribes (NT) and Semi Nomadic Tribes (SNT) are the most neglected and discriminated marginalized section of contemporary Indian Society. Pastoral, hunter gatherers, traders, transporters, craft workers, entertainers, foragers and such communities are losing their traditional forms of livelihood due to various changes. The process of their economic marginalization began during the British rule with the introduction of railway, industries and rule of law. This deprivation continued with various non-inclusive developmental drives and Acts. Modern science, technology and economics are failed to provide them any safeguards. Communities like jugglers, acrobats, tight -rope walker, Snake-Monkey-Bear player are forced to accept deteriorating life, in the absence of sound alternatives. Environmental degradation and the whole ecological distress have been put forwarded many problems to pastoral communities. Mega project like Dams, Road, and Special Economic Zones creates complications to them. Laws and Policies of forest and social forestry blocked the way of fuel and fodder for these communities and their livestock. Indian history also remembers a cruel colonial legacy in the form of The Criminal tribes Act 1871 and its shadow
Social exclusion in India: nomadic tribes community of Maharashtra
Short Abstract
The Nomadic and Denotified Tribes have been suffering due to the absence of a means of livelihood and the stigma of criminality. They are not able to enjoy human rights and civil rights available to the citizens of India due to lack of Constitutional safeguards.
Long Abstract
The Nomadic and Denotified tribes constitute about five million of population in Maharashtra and about 60 million all over India. There are 313 Nomadic Tribes and 198 Denotified Tribes. The large section of these tribes is known as "Vimukta jaatis" or the Ex-Criminal Tribes because they were branded as criminals by birth.However, they have been deprived of the status of Scheduled Tribes provided by the constitution due to certain historical circumstances and the acts of omission and commission on part of the Government and the society. The Nomadic and Denotified Tribes are National tribes. They have no place of their own. Hitherto, their life is a long tale of suffering and persecution due to the absence of a means of livelihood and the stigma of criminality attached to them by the sedentary society. While it may take years and years to remove this stigma, the injustice meted out to them due to the act of omission and neglect could well be corrected without any further delay. It will be impossible for these tribes to enjoy human rights or the civil rights available to the citizens of India unless there is a positive intervention of the government in the form of Constitutional safeguards. This paper seeks to present the Indian problem from a historical and contemporary perspective with a view to help in developing a just, equal, and humane society in India.
Issues and Challenges of Inclusion of De-notified Tribes in Democratic Secular India
Short Abstract
The study analyzes and examines the eleven indicators of democracy and secularism among the de-notified tribes of Solapur City, Maharashtra India
Long Abstract
The present study is made with a holistic approach to analyses the present situation of De-notified tribes in democratic secular India. The study has focused on eleven indicators of democracy given by National Democratic Institute. The study compares the indicators and its awareness among the de-notified tribes. The study explores the ground situation of the democracy and secularism in de-notified tribes of Solapur city. The study reveals the needs and challenges of inclusion of de-notified tribes into the main stream of democracy and secularism. The study also recommends for policy interventions and possible modules of inclusive development of de-notified tribes.
Law and loss of livelihood: the Hawadigas and Qalandars of Karnataka, India
Short Abstract
It examines the impact of law on social, economic and cultural life of the semi-nomadic indigenous communities of Hawadigas (Snake Charmers) and Qalandars (Bear Charmers) in Karnataka, India and how it has has resulted in their exclusion? It argues for the need to recognize and restore their cultural rights.
Long Abstract
This paper scrutinizes the impact of wildlife protection and animal welfare laws on social, economic and cultural life of the indigenous and semi-nomadic communities of Hawadigas (Snake Charmers) and Qalandars (Bear Charmers) in Karnataka and focuses on the question as to how law has resulted in exclusion of Hawadigas and Qalandars?
National and international instruments have been reviewed and testimonials of violence by state and non-state actors have been collected and analysed. It critically analyses the Indian laws viz. the Prevention of Cruelty to Animal Act 1960; and the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972, which treat the community criminal because they traditionally possess, inherit, train and exhibit snakes and sloth bears. It also traces the nature and legality of violence perpetrated on these communities by the police, forest department and animal rights NGOs.
The paper argues for the need to recognize and restore their cultural rights in line with the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) and also to initiate a process of reparation and rehabilitation of the community to enable them to chose their future.
Somewhere between Forests and Modernity: Transforming exclusions, criminalities and resistance in nomadic hunting tribes
Short Abstract
The criminalisation of hunting in India has reconfigured exclusion and criminality for many nomadic tribals, besides creating a crisis in livelihoods. The paper addresses this relationship amidst inept developmental measures, attempts at resistance and a rush to access India's evolving modernity.
Long Abstract
This paper addresses the complexities emerging through the interaction between the current development discourse in India, the conservation movements spearheaded by 'Project Tiger' and hunting-gathering nomadic 'ex-criminal' tribes. Drawing from an extensive study of the Pardhi-Baheliya community in Central India, an attempt is made to highlight paradoxes surrounding development that are slowly driving many members of this tribe from their traditional occupation (primarily hunting, which is currently illegal under the Wildlife Protection Act) to hardened criminal activities in a desperate search for livelihoods.
In the backdrop of haphazard conservation policies that are not complemented by appropriate inclusion measures, the experience of the Pardhi community highlights a typical case of denied citizenship, livelihoods and dignity amidst an exclusionary caste laced system. The paper further engages with the 'invisibility' of such Denotified communities within the modern state and argues for subtle acts of everyday resistance by their members through which attempts are being made to forcibly enter India's developmental discourse.
In addition, the paper draws from experiences of NGOs and Government of India departments that are currently involved in developmental interventions towards the Pardhis wherein successes have been rare. Therefore, the unique circumstances of such nomadic communities that are overlooked within the current developmental thinking have also been emphasised.
The paper, thus, unravels the intricate connections between forests, the state, NGOs, nomadic peoples, citizenship, resistance and criminality while placing in perspective political, economic as well as environmental concerns.
STRATEGIES FOR ENSURING INCLUSION OF DNT COMMUNITIES IN INDIA
Short Abstract
Exclusion of DNT Communities in India is a cause of worry. In order to ensure inclusion of this diverse community, there is need to mobilize communities, its leaders and sensitize policy makers for which a systematic approach is required. This paper aims at developing strategies for action.
Long Abstract
In this panel, several papers have described realistic picture of the situation of DNT communities in India and have also explained the nature of exclusion. Since the majority of the DNTs communities basically move from one place to another for living, is a big challenge for community mobilization. Though most of the communities have cast based associations, they are not united on the unique and larger identity of "DNT Communities" which itself is a major challenge. Unless these communities come together under one banner and fight unitedly for their demands, their voice will not be heard by the politicians, bureaucrats s, policy makers and planners. Since there are more than 600 communities, their leaders are also large in number having different ideologies and approaches hence uniting the leaders is another major challenge. On the other hand, one has to make systematic case for inclusion of these communities which will be research based and well documented. Hence there is need to have a multi-disciplinary approach for the inclusion.
This paper aims at developing the strategies as stated above for their inclusion.
This panel is closed to new paper proposals.
Congress Agenda
This congress is sponsored by:

