Evolving humanity, emerging worlds
Manchester, UK; 5th-10th August 2013
(SE09)
Living heritage in China today
Location Museum
Date and Start Time 07 Aug, 2013 at 09:00
Convenors
Sharon Macdonald (University of York)
email
Xiaoyang Zhu (Peking University)
email
Mail All Convenors
Short Abstract
This panel is concerned with the lived experience of cultural heritage policies and globalization in contemporary China. It invites contributions based on in-depth ethnographic research that explore the social consequences of current heritage developments, conflicts and practices.
Long Abstract
The aim of this panel is to look at some of the pressing questions of the globalization of cultural heritage through presenting recent research on the lived experience of cultural heritage policies in China today. China has an extensive system of laws and policies aimed at preserving intangible and tangible heritage at both national and regional/city levels, as well as numerous institutions and practices for preserving or enhancing cultural heritage. These range from academic departments dealing with cultural heritage management techniques and the development of conservation, through to associations for training in certain forms of traditional artistic production, and support for travel by dance troupes or musicians. A growth of tourism - both by domestic and international tourists - has also encouraged the maintenance and performance of traditional culture. At the same time, however, major building programmes - that simultaneously entail the destruction of older buildings or areas - are underway in many parts of China. There is also continuing urbanization and movement of young people in particular away from rural areas, thus weakening traditional forms of transmission of cultural knowledge and offering alternative ways of living.
The panel convenors invite contributions based on in-depth research that explore different dimensions of the lived experience heritage developments, conflicts and practices in contemporary China.
This panel is closed to new paper proposals.
Papers
The Materialist Urbanization and the War of Gods
Short Abstract
The paper, in the first place, examines the role of spirituality and belief played in the struggle over the material space in the process of China's urbanization, especially the so-called "transforming the urban villages in city" (chengzhongcun gaizao).
Long Abstract
These gods partake in the fight for spaces in the demolishment campaigns, thus being renewed and strengthened by different players. I will provide a description of these war of "gods", and explore human spirituality and belief intermingled in the war against materials in a time of "materialization."
The second theme of the paper is to interpret 'Home' (家园), a frequent key symbol in the process of China's urbanization and urban redevelopment. In recent years, it has become a common practice for Chinese citizens to resort to the slogan of 'protecting our homes' in their campaigns to protect their legitimate rights and interests.
'Home protection' is in line with the basic political doctrine in Chinese socio-cultural discourse. For example, it goes with the idea of 'protecting one's life and one's own home'(保护身家性命). At present, the politics of ordinary people and their political life starts with how they feel about their homes and how they protect them. The concept of 'home' thus does not go well with such fashionable concepts as community, civil society, or 'individual-society' in socio-political theories. When 'home' becomes the starting point of substratum political practice, socio-political theories should consider a paradigm shift to the study of 'body, home and nation/country'. For example, a political study on opposing officialdom should start with the experience of 'body-home', replacing the idea of 'state -society' and the polarized social theory of 'individual vs. society' with a framework of 'body, home, nation/country and universe(身家国天下)'.
An anthropological study of the Uyghur meshrep in contemporary Xinjiang
Short Abstract
This paper examines the process of the Uyghur meshrep using Victor Turner's theory of ritual process in three phases. It seeks to establish that the ritual practice of the meshrep has been playing a key role in strengthening traditional forms of transmission of culture among the Uyghurs in Xinjiang.
Long Abstract
The Uyghur meshrep in Xinjiang is a ritual practice among the Uyghurs which includes a series of cultural activities such as performing music, singing, dancing, telling jokes, drama, poetry, games, penalty activities, and etc. In 2010, the Uyghur meshrep was in the UNESCO's List of Intangible Cultural Heritage in Need of Urgent Safeguarding. While highly valued for its social roles, the Uyghur meshrep in Xinjiang today increasingly faces new challenges in the wake of the globalization of the Han dominant majority culture. Although many studies have been conducted on the characteristics of music, dance and literature of the Uyghur meshrep, research applying anthropological theories to examine anthropological aspects of the Uyghur meshrep is rare. Using Victor Turner's theory of ritual process, this paper analyses the process and characteristics of the Uyghur meshrep in three phases, namely preliminality, liminality and post-liminality. This paper seeks to establish that the ritual practice of the meshrep has been playing an important role in strengthening traditional forms of transmission of cultural knowledge among the Uyghurs in contemporary Xinjiang.
Authenticity and Heritage Policies in China: Interpretation, Conflicts and Practices
Short Abstract
This article examines the value of authenticity, its interpretation, and consequences for heritage conservation practices in China. It argues that heritage polices in China has attempted to develop its own idea of authenticity through learning from not only the “international principles”, but also its historical experiences, and the local practices.
Long Abstract
Rooted in Western ideals of heritage preservation, the authenticity approach takes on new meanings in China as it is interpreted and implemented with a government-led approach implicated in the Chinese state's political and economic strategies. Meanwhile, the global movement of heritage conservationists on authenticity becomes continuously and dynamically negotiated with respect to local conditions. The juxtaposition of different value systems on heritage policies in the process of globalization and modernization continuously leads to diverse practices in China. The notion of authenticity has emerged as practices for local govenment, tourism operators or companies' engagement in the heritage discourse and thus acts as a locus for new forms of agency.
Drawing on 12 months fieldwork in southwest China, this paper examines the politics of conservation for both tangible and intangible heritage in China and the complex role authenticity plays in the process. I argue that the Chinese official interpretation for authenticity has increasingly confronted the shifting power structure of new social orders constructed by different actors in the social network. Different value systems have been conflicting and negotiating with each other against the background of the country's political, social and economic transitions. Regarding the practices of heritage development, the search for authenticity has formed a lived and dynamic presentation through the local development of modernization, commercialization and marketization.
From Living Fossils to Living Heritage: Ecomuseum Development in Southwest China
Short Abstract
This paper explores how imaginings of ethnic minorities have transformed from living fossils to living heritage in modern China, specifically through new museological approaches like the ecomuseum.
Long Abstract
In the 1950s, ethnic minority groups in China assumed new positionalities and identities under the national identification program. Under a new system of ethnic classification, applying the Stalin ethnic nationality five criteria approach and Morgan-Engelsian evolutionary theory, ethnic minority were designated social "living fossils". Thus began a new policy for ethnic minority nationalities whereby they were located along social lines, deemed "primitive" and "backward" compared to the "modern" Han, and required integration into the modern socialist nation. From a museological perspective, ethnic minorities have been framed between the 1950s to the early 1980s under this ethnic discourse. In the context of a recent trend museum development and tangible and intangible heritage protection since the 1990s ethnic minority cultures have been reimagined as "living cultural heritage". The establishment of ecomuseum projects in southwest China as an attempt to preserve ethnic minority cultural heritage in-situ differs from traditional displays that communicate constructed bounded, a-political, and a-historical ethnic identities, are representative of this endeavor to mark ethnic minorities as living heritage. This paper explores the historical ideological shift in imaginings of ethnic minorities in modern China. Drawing on fieldwork in Guizhou and Guangxi, this paper elucidates how ecomuseums are spaces where local ethnic minority populations are imagined as "living heritage" and where local ethnic minority populations use such political rhetoric to imagine their own ethnicity and heritage, and create new subjectivities. Yet, through such new museological approaches can ethnic minorities escape the living fossil discourse?
Local Histories and New Museological Approaches in China
Short Abstract
398 new museums were born in China in 2011, half of which represent the recent trend in new museology in China. This paper introduces these new local museums that offer traditionally unrepresented and unofficial local histories through the display of oral histories and collective memories.
Long Abstract
We are becoming increasingly aware of museum boom and new trends of museum movement in China, yet a theoretically informed and methodologically systematic study assessing the meaning of new museum practices is still lacking. This paper investigates China new museum movement by diachronic and synchronic approaches, and tells what is happening in China right now within the development of new museological approaches. In 2011, 398 museums were established in China making the list now come to approximately 3700 nation-wide. Almost half of these new museums are about local village history. They represent a foundation upon which the construction of new interpretations and expressions of local histories are made and displayed, specifically rooted in oral history and collective memory. These local history museums are a new approach to museology in China in that they offer an unofficial history of local place and society, unlike traditional museums that promote national history narratives. From these local history museums, we can learn the multiple histories and life of local villages and villagers that have historically been unrepresented in Chinese museums. Looking at specific practices among these new museums, this paper introduces the change in museological approaches in China, specifically reviewing the shift in museological philosophy in the evaluation of objects, museology, technological practices, and curatorial methods recently introducing the protection of intangible cultural heritage. This paper will also address how the focus of local exhibitions has changed from displaying a macro history to now local stories and memories, providing a living history.
Practice & Research on Recovery of Traditional Chinese Xuan Paper Technology
Short Abstract
Paper is one of the four great inventions in ancient China and also plays a key role in the world modernization together with printing.The core objective of this documentary project is to utilize local natural materials and traditional technology to recover the making flow of high-quality Xuan paper.
Long Abstract
Paper is one of the four great inventions in ancient China and also plays a key role in the world modernization together with printing. Meanwhile, Xuan paper makes contributions to development of Chinese traditional painting art, as the thousand-year Xuan paper preserves painting works perfectly and makes it possible to hand these works down from generation to generation. However, only the paper strictly made according to traditional technology can display the creation of painters maximally and has longer lifetime. The core objective of this documentary project is to utilize local natural materials and traditional technology to recover the making flow of high-quality Xuan paper.
Shadow Play in Guanzhong Area (1978~2008): A Case Study for Culture Heritage in China's Rural Area
Short Abstract
From the view of sociology, this report tries to study the discipline of social-cultural changes, setting on the case of Hua’xian Shadow Play. We propose the perspective endogenous of China's rural social and cultural.
Long Abstract
The rural area development is one of the most crucial problems in nowadays China. As we know, the inner structure of rural community and the rural policies of the nation are affecting the individual village from within and above, so the policies coming from outside world can hardly join the metabolism system of rural society. From the view of sociology, this report tries to study the discipline of social-cultural changes, setting on the case of Hua'xian Shadow Play. We propose the perspective endogenous of China's rural social and cultural. And try on the logic among the mode of production, lifestyle, demographic composition and cultural consumption patterns. Then we do some thinking on the structural changes of the rural culture of thinking.
The Embodied Experiences of Heritage: Bearers of Tradition in Zhejiang
Short Abstract
This paper addresses informal and officially promoted so-called representative bearers (daibiao chuancheng renwu) of tradition in Zhejiang province. In China the government has nominated representative bearers of tradition in different fields and on different levels of the state administration. The paper provides an overview of this policy and the selection process at both the national and local level. One crucial issue is whether such a policy helps protect the intangible and tangible heritage and what other mechanisms and local grassroots initiatives that exists. The paper focuses on both bearers of tradition within the religious field as well as intangible heritage nominations in the form of ancestral ceremonies and temple festivals as they are closely interlinked. My case study consists of two villages in Zhejiang and is based on participation temple festivals and ancestral ceremonies as well as interviews with those who organise them and who are involved in the writing and printing of genealogies and other important objects used in the rituals.
Long Abstract
This paper addresses informal and officially promoted so-called representative bearers (daibiao chuancheng renwu) of tradition in Zhejiang province. In China the government has nominated representative bearers of tradition in different fields and on different levels of the state administration. The paper provides an overview of this policy and the selection process at both the national and local level. One crucial issue is whether such a policy helps protect the intangible and tangible heritage and what other mechanisms and local grassroots initiatives that exists. The paper focuses on both bearers of tradition within the religious field as well as intangible heritage nominations in the form of ancestral ceremonies and temple festivals as they are closely interlinked. My case study consists of two villages in Zhejiang and is based on participation temple festivals and ancestral ceremonies as well as interviews with those who organise them and who are involved in the writing and printing of genealogies and other important objects used in the rituals.
The New Chinese Museology: sihting borders and alterantive heritages
Short Abstract
China has committed resources to a large museum/theme park development plan with support from international agencies and support.Yet these developments raise alternatives to well established ideas of collecting and preserving pasts in China.
Long Abstract
China has committed resources to a large museum/theme park development plan with support from international agencies and support. Yet it occurs at the same time as the huge destruction of urban and rural landscapes. The paradox relates to a deeper question of the role of museums in development , in the branding of cities having heritage value and the long term role of museums relating to well established ideas of collecting and preserving pasts in China.
plans
ʻLandscapesʼ in Pictures: Visible and Invisible in Minority Tourism of Dai People
Short Abstract
In contemporary China, visible images, which are taken or made from minority tour, on the one hand, transform memorial and ritual interpretation by means of photos and videos ; on the other hand, all kinds of images not only involve the meanings of tourist gaze but present different deep-seated ideologies of different interest groups; further more, also represent interesting relations between tangible materials and corporeal images. I would like to analysis and interpret them with my case-study of Dai, in Yunnan, China.
Long Abstract
In contemporary China, images are playing a vey important role in minority tourism. The two parts integrated together, and even can not be separated from each other. Meanwhile, with the decolonisation and postmodernism, meanings of photos in tour are also getting a great change. Visible images, which are taken or made from minority tour, on the one hand, transform memorial and ritual interpretation by means of photos and videos ; on the other hand, all kinds of images not only involve the meanings of tourist gaze but present different deep-seated ideologies of different interest groups; further more, also represent interesting relations between tangible materials and corporeal images. I would like to analysis and interpret them with my case-study of Dai, in Yunnan, China.
This panel is closed to new paper proposals.
Congress Agenda
This congress is sponsored by:

