Evolving humanity, emerging worlds
Manchester, UK; 5th-10th August 2013
(SE10)
Are tribes actors in the 21st century?
Location University Place 1.218
Date and Start Time 09 Aug, 2013 at 16:30
Convenor
Philip Carl Salzman (McGill University)
email
Mail All Convenors
Short Abstract
Tribes are often thought of as primordial social forms displaced by the state and by civilization. And yet tribes continue to appear and act in practical affairs. What is the current status of tribes, how and why do they mobilize, and why do tribes continue to exist and operate?
Long Abstract
Tribes are often thought of as primordial social forms displaced by the state and by civilization. Except by some "postcolonial" anthropologists who do not grant "tribe" an authentic indigenous existence, dismissing it as an invention of reactionary and racist anthropologists and colonialists.
And yet we are repeatedly surprised by the appearance and agency in practical affairs of these allegedly imaginary entities. The Pashtun tribes side with the Taliban against the Western forces, or resist the Taliban; assert their independence in the tribal regions, and attack the Pakistani Government. The tribes of al-Anbar Province of Iraq were active participants with al-Qaeda in the anti-Western insurgency, but later switched to ally with the Americans against al-Qaeda. The Bedouin tribes of Cyrenaica, Libya, who fought two wars with the Italians, and who continued to be local political players during the Gadhafi regime, led the rebellion against Gadhafi, and are now likely to contest power in the new Libya. The Yarahmadzai tribe of Iranian Baluchistan that I lived with and studied would be more than surprised to hear that no such entity actually existed, or was invented by me, or by colonialists (none of whom ever managed to arrive in the region).
This panel presents an opportunity for researchers from various regions to explore the current status of tribes, to consider the ways and extent to which they mobilize, and for what purposes, and to theorize why tribes continue to exist and operate in the contemporary world.
This panel is closed to new paper proposals.
Papers
Tribes in the Middle East and Central Asia
Short Abstract
Independent tribes are polities based upon collective responsibility and self help, with the means of coercion distributed throughout the population.
Tribes effectively encapsulated by states become identity and interest groups, mobilizing their members for defense, influence, and patronage.
Long Abstract
In Iranian Baluchistan, the Sarhadi tribes were politically independent during the later Qajar period, but were effectively encapsulated by Reza Shah in 1935 after a military campaign. Following the fall of the Pahlavi dynasty in the late 1979 during the Islamic Revolution, the Baluch tribes rose and fought Persian Sistanis for control of Zahedan, the provincial capital, but were eventually suppressed by the forces of the Islamic Revolution. Encapsulated once again, the tribes have been submerged in a flood of Shia Persians from outside the province, who have rapidly increased urbanization, commerce, and education. A resistence movement, the Jundallah, based in the Rigi tribe, has attacked state security forces on behalf of the interests of the Baluchi Sunni population.
The Kirgiz tribes were incorporated into the Russian Empire in the 19th century, and launched a costly and losing rebellion in the early 20th century. Under the Russian Empire, and its successor the Soviet Union, tribes as independent polities were suppressed. But the tribes continued as identity and interest groups, capable of mobilizing members, and sought and won patronage on their behalf. With the fall of the U.S.S.R. in 1992, some Kirgiz turned to a revivification and formalization of tribes (just as others turned to Islam or Western development) in response to the vacuum of organization and purpose.
Pastoral Nomads of Iran after Iranian Revolution of 1978-79
Short Abstract
This paper will explore situation of Pastoral nomads after revolution in Iran. With an overview on political, environmental, and religious changings of nomads life after revolution, this paper try to give an up-to-date report regarding the actual roles of pastoral nomads in Iranian policy.
Long Abstract
This paper will explore situation of Pastoral nomads after revolution in Iran. With an overview on political, environmental, and religious changings of nomads life after revolution, this paper try to give an up-to-date report regarding the actual roles of pastoral nomads in Iranian policy.
Tribes in Libya From 1900 To Now
Short Abstract
I investigate the changing role played by named descent groups, called here ‘tribes’, in Libya. Focusing on the relationships between tribes and the Senussi religious fraternity of the early 1900s, the revolutionary committees of the 70s and 80s, and the contemporary civil war, highlights this change.
Long Abstract
I investigate the changing role played by named descent groups, which I will refer to as 'tribes', in Libya from the early 1900s to now. Focusing on the types and instances of reported interactions between Libyan tribes and the Senussi religious fraternity, Qaddafi's revolutionary committees, and the modern militias that prosecuted Libya's most recent war, shows how Libyan tribes have changed and adapted to new socioeconomic circumstances. For instance, tribal interaction with the Senussi was a seemingly structural instance of inter-group mediation through shared religious sentiment (Evans-Pritchard 1949, Peters 1968), whereas tribal influence on local elections (circa 1975) seems a clearer instance of political complimentary opposition wherein local Shaikhs attempted to equalize the respective representation of oppositional parties (Davis 1987). Drawing nearer to the present it becomes more difficult to ascertain - with history's ad hoc precision - categorical instances of tribal interaction with Libyan life and politics. Granting this, media reportage of the war in Libya points, in most cases, to some level of tribal participation/influence inside of the various rebel militias that supported the National Transitional Council. Research I conducted in the summer of 2012 aimed to more fully discern the nature of this involvement.
On the ambivalence of belonging: (de)constructing tribal identity in the 21st century
Short Abstract
The paper aims to explore different forces that are associated with the (de)construction of ethnic identity and its ramification for Scheduled Tribes in Odisha.
Long Abstract
Foundational research on identity formation attributed more on the communitarian notion of belonging and solidarity. This notion is recently being questioned, arguing that the identity formation is more complex and ambivalent than previously depicted. The notion of 'ethnic identity' is constructed, reconstructed and deconstructed (as in the case of Scheduled Tribes of Narayanpatna block of Koraput district, Odisha, India) through socio-historical processes. Identities are contextual and develop as a result of the tribal communities' day-to-day interaction with outsiders in Odisha. It has to be understood that borders and identities are human creations, their constructs affected by our own political perception. Every group identity/boundary is an expression and exercise of power in one form or the other. In India, identities of inclusion/exclusion play a major role in societal allocation of resources due to various attempts of ethnic groups to favour their group members over non-members. This disposition becomes important in social and political life when people and group of people have to compete for scarce resources. Most of these boundaries are fluid and contestable, calling for an understanding of the social, political, cultural and economic forces that cause these boundaries to shift and be altered over time. Engaging the lives of the real people caught on the margins can lead to new understandings of often invisible forces shaping and reshaping their identities. So, the major concern of the paper is to explore the interplay between different forces and (de)construction of ethnic identities and its ramification for Scheduled Tribes in Odisha, India.
This panel is closed to new paper proposals.
Congress Agenda
This congress is sponsored by:

