Accesskey 1: Go straight to homepage | Accesskey 2: Go straight to the main content of each page | Accesskey 3: Go straight to the Login page | Accesskey 4: Go straight to the Search box | Accesskey 5: Go straight to the directory | Accesskey 6: Go straight to the contact page | Accesskey 7: Go straight to the resources page | Accesskey 9: Go straight to the networks page | Accesskey 0: Go straight to the accessibility page |


FIND US ON:
FACEBOOK & TWITTER

EASA is a member of

WCAA

EASA, 2008: EASA08: Experiencing diversity and mutuality

Ljubljana, 26/08/2008 – 29/08/2008

(W072)

Mutuality at a distance - transnational social space

Location 532
Date and Start Time 29 Aug, 2008 at 09:00

Convenors

Anna Wojtyńska (University of Iceland) email
Unnur Dís Skaptadóttir (University of Iceland) email
Wojciech Burszta (Warsaw School of Social Psychology) email
Mail All Convenors

Short Abstract

In this workshop we welcome papers that discuss transnational activities of today's migrants that stimulate transnational space focusing on issues such as multiple identity, belonging, participation, gendered migration, class differences, and transnational families.

Long Abstract

Recent years have been characterized by the changing patterns of people's mobility in Europe and all over the world. Although individuals continue to relocate elsewhere to find better places to live there is also growing short term mobility and pendulum movements. Consequently more and more places face diversity and mutuality on local and national level. With current communication technology and cheap airfares migration does not have to indicate abandoning the communites of origin. Multiple examples from around the world illustrate how people continue to act and participate in the local life in their countries of origin based on solidarity, obligations and reciprocity. Simultaneously they also participate in local life in the host society. Thus they are involved in two places in economic, religious, political, and emotional contexts.

These migration patterns pose new challenges for anthropological theory and research methods. The questions of integration and transnational activities are interlinked.

In this workshop we welcome papers that discuss transnational activities of today's migrants, which stimulate transnational social space. We would like to invite papers discussing different aspects related to transnational practices performed by contemporary migrants such as identity, belonging, participation, gendered migration, class differences, and transnational families.

Chair: Anna Wojtynska
Discussant: Wojciech Józef Burszta and Unnur Dis Skaptadottir

Papers

Integration and transnational practices

Author: Unnur Dís Skaptadóttir (University of Iceland)  email
Mail All Authors

Long Abstract

The prominence of research on transnational relations, multiple identities and anti-essentialist approaches have challenged anthropological research on ethnicity, migration and multicultural society. This occurs in the context of rising politics against multiculturalism in Europe. My analysis focuses on the relationship between individual transnational activities and integration based on research among people who have migrated to Iceland from the Philippines in the last two decades. While working mostly in low paid jobs in Iceland, most of them participate in family life in their countries of origin based on solidarity, obligations and reciprocity. The transnational practises of sending remittances and keeping in touch with family "back home" shape the meanings of both places. The paper will take people's agency and diverse experiences into account as well as the larger structures that limit their activities, such as the changing labour market in Europe that increasingly excludes those coming from outside Europe.

Identities and transnational migratory spaces: female migrants from the former Soviet Union in Slovenia

Author: Sanja Cukut (Slovenian Academy of Sciences and Arts)  email
Mail All Authors

Long Abstract

The contribution will, through the analysis of life stories of women from the former Soviet Union in Slovenia, present their conceptualisations of 'home', ethnic and cultural belonging. Processes of multiple belonging and identity formation, traced in the stories, point to the complexity and fluidity of migrant subjectivities and reveal multiple subject positions at the intersection of gender, class and ethnicity. In this respect, ethnic and cultural belongings are themselves fluid, and context-dependent as neither the 'country of origin' nor the 'new society' can be understood as homogenous, static entities. However, transnational movement causes contradictory processes that pertain to both inclusion and exclusion of migrants and contain mutually competitive discourses: the idea of human rights and equal treatment of all individuals; and the exclusion from different rights (for instance, social and employment rights, inability to gain dual citizenship, privileging the 'classical marriage' model) and racisms (for example, the 'sexualised' images of women from the former Soviet Union as exotic dancers and prostitutes, the construction of the 'Eastern female') experienced by migrants. I will trace such a contradiction in EU discourses, which both promote freedom and openness and create new stratifications by severely restricting transnational movement of third-country nationals across the EU. The paper will reveal the heterogeneity and diversity of individual experiences and argue that heterogeneity of migrants might be a crucial starting point for devising integration policies which should address different migrants' needs and experiences and their relation to the country of origin through various transnational practices.

Elderly women with Ingrian background across the Finnish-Russian border: the questions of identity, belonging and mutual care.

Author: Tatiana Tiaynen (University of Tampere)  email
Mail All Authors

Long Abstract

The collapse of the Soviet system followed by the difficult cultural transformation together with ethnic mobility and transnational migration, which have specifically increased on both sides of the Finnish-Russian border in 1990s, have had an impact on identity formation process, inter- generational relation and family forms in the Finnish-Russian borderland. This paper focuses on the Ingrian Finns case, an ethnic group which was subjected to the discriminative Soviet policy having been significantly affecting the people's every day life and identities. This paper is documentary based, and contains the in-depth-interviews of elderly women with Ingrian background. Some of the women have moved to Finland, while others have stayed in Russian Karelia (Petrozavodsk). Addressing of issues such as multiple identities, national and ethnic identities, memory and sense of belonging I seek to explore these women's identity formation and reconstruction process in the context of the post-Soviet cultural transformation and migration to Finland. As all the women are involved in transnational families across the Finnish-Russian border I also aimed at the examination of their role in those, and the effect of transnational experiences upon their identities.

The systems of mutual assistance among the Africans in moscow

Author: Sergey Serov  email
Mail All Authors

Long Abstract

Four systems of mutual assistance have been singled out for the research:

• the assistance the African newcomers get from their relatives that remain in home countries;

• the assistance the already well-adapted in Moscow Africans provide to their relatives in home countries;

• the assistance the well-adapted Moscow Africans provide to their recently arrived compatriots;

• the assistance the African newcomers get from Russians.

All the kinds of assistance were studied: practical (financial support, accommodation, etc.), information (sharing the

knowledge necessary for successful interaction with the immigration services, university administration, etc.),

psychological (support in hardships, spending leisure time together, etc.).

It was also important for us to find out the factors affecting the assistance providing and their strength. The most

significant among them are as follows:

• the degree of kin and affinity closeness;

• gender;

• ethnic origin;

• religion;

• country of origin.

The methods employed are questionnaire interrogation and interview, well-elaborated and recognized as highly valid

in contemporary social anthropology.

The significance of the research is determined not by its academic importance only but by its possible and desirable

practical outcomes as well: Its results can be used for improving the Moscow Africans' position what will no doubt be

beneficial for the Russian society as a whole.

Leavers and stayers discuss returning home

Author: Aleksandra Galasinska (University of Wolverhampton)  email
Mail All Authors

Long Abstract

There is a significant difference between the previous waves of Polish migrants and the massive outflow of people from Poland after the EU expansion. Information technologies enable post-accession migrants to participate actively in an ongoing dialogue with those who stayed in the home country about, among others, various social issues related to the process of the post-communist transformation. This paper discusses an electronic newspaper forum as an example of transnational space of participation in a recreated civil society.

Recently there has been an on-going debate in the Polish media about a possible return of the post-04 migrants. Newspapers and magazines emphasise the economic (very strong Polish currency) as well as the political arguments (change of a government for the more liberal one) in order to explain that a mass return might happen.

Both migrants and 'non-migrants' make comments on the issues and they post their views on internet forums of a number of e-papers. Anchoring the study in narrative and discourse analyses, I shall investigate topics and lines of argumentation of forum participants. I shall also describe the differences and similarities between "non-migrants'" and migrants' entries. In doing so I hope to shed a light on the role of such internet sites as translocal platforms of a new form of involvement in a public sphere.

The data come from approximately 350 entries on an internet forum triggered by newspaper reports and articles in the electronic version of the 'Gazeta Wyborcza' between January and March 2008.

'Welcome to the FoE family': the constitution and maintenance of mutuality at a distance in a transnational community

Author: Caroline Gatt (Sociological Review)  email
Mail All Authors

Long Abstract

Three key issues arise from my research in the transnational milieu of Friends of the Earth International (FoEI): 1) how mutuality is maintained at a distance; 2) how mutuality between FoEI activists is constituted; 3) how attention to the specific dynamics of mutuality is critical to understanding group cohesion. FoEI is a long-standing international federation of environmental non-governmental organisations. It is made up of activists who participate in FoEI from their respective homes all around the world and identify themselves as belonging to what they call the "FoE family". Mutuality at a distance is based on shared work and daily communication done by telephone and over the Internet. In practice these media 'fold' the geographical distance between the activists. However, an exploration of FoEI annual meetings shows that this mutuality largely depends on certain face-to-face practices carried out during these events. In fact, these annual meetings can be understood as rituals that establish new activists' initial sense of mutuality and reinforce existing relations. The practices of communion and communicative action within these rituals provide concrete insights into the constitution of mutuality. These findings challenge notions of identity as defined primarily through alterity. In particular, the activists' experiences of mutuality at a distance highlight processes where alterity is only one of the many aspects involved in the way their group coheres. Consequently, what is called for is a more multi-faceted understanding of group identity and cohesion; One that explains the minutiae of mutuality as well as alterity in understanding social groups.

Download PDF of paper

Liquid lives: migration in the times of globalisation

Author: Anna Wojtyńska (University of Iceland)  email
Mail All Authors

Long Abstract

International migration flows belong to the global processes. Experiences of contemporary migrants are shaped not only by the involvement in cross-border mobility but also (post) modern transformations in society. Their identities, modes of belonging, family patterns, associations and networking are as much influenced by migration as so-called global culture in which migrants participate.

Taking the case of Poles living in Iceland I am going to discuss the shifting notions of national identity, community and kinship. I will present different linkages Polish migrants establish with the sending country. However, contrary to findings from other scholarly works, sustained contacts Poles keep with place of origin does not necessarily lead to establishing transnational community. I suggest then, that transnationalism in migration studies should not be reduced to the various practices migrants pursue across the borders, but more as a condition and potential for emergence transnational social spaces.

Cambodian refugees and naturalization

Author: Giovanna Cavatorta (Università di Padova / EHESS Paris)  email
Mail All Authors

Long Abstract

This paper is about a fieldwork with Cambodian refugees in Ile de France. More in particular it is focused, and identifies, Cambodian refugees which are passed through the French asylum dispositive. By following the critical anthropological perspective in refugees studies, aim of the ethnography is questioning the self-reduction which laws and subjectivity experts make, by constructing a refugee which is cultural and ethnical fixed.

Existential anthropology will be useful to approach refugees' experiences and memories in their social dimension. This forces us dealing with relations between the first and second generation, and face the silences which the 'survivors' deserve to their children in everyday interactions and growth. Silences which seem not to deal with the work which this diaspora make, consisting in a transnational activity of claiming recovery. It's by the articulation of this two expressions of the genocidal violence, which can help us to problematize the 'survivor' category. The enejeux is positioning their experiences, here and now, in the arriving national-state; this implies face the particular citizenship which French multicultural society promote. Anthropology, as the critique of the common sense, should so investigate how the self-evidences of a belonging are changed and perceived by those citizens; how the agency is mold, in the social and domestic, space by 'khmer' and 'french' cosmological references.

Focusing on the passage, this people chose, by refugees status to naturalization, ask us to reconsider analytic categories, and the interpretative violence into which social sciences can incur.